Delaware mattersBiden was a familiar figure to his Delaware constituency, by virtue of his daily train commuting from there,[17] and generally sought to attend to state needs.[142] Biden was a strong supporter of increased Amtrak funding and rail security;[142] he hosted barbecues and an annual Christmas dinner for the Amtrak crews, and they would sometimes hold the last train of the night a few minutes so he could catch it.[41][142] He earned the nickname "Amtrak Joe" as a result (and in 2011, Amtrak's Wilmington Station was named the Joseph R. Biden Jr. Railroad Station, in honor of the over 7,000 trips he made from there).[143][144] He was an advocate for Delaware military installations, including Dover Air Force Base and New Castle Air National Guard Base.[145] In 1975, Biden broke from liberal orthodoxy when he took legislative action to limit desegregation busing.[77] In doing so, he said busing was a "bankrupt idea [that violated] the cardinal rule of common sense," and that his opposition would make it easier for other liberals to follow suit.[77] Three years later, Wilmington's federally mandated cross-district busing plan generated much turmoil, and in trying to legislate a compromise solution, Biden found himself alienating both black and white voters for a while.[146] Beginning in 1991, Biden served as an adjunct professor at the Widener University School of Law, Delaware's only law school, teaching a seminar on constitutional law.[147][148] The seminar was one of Widener's most popular, often with a waiting list for enrollment.[148] Biden typically co-taught the course with another professor, taking on at least half the course minutes and sometimes flying back from overseas to make one of the classes.[149][150] Biden was a sponsor of bankruptcy legislation during the 2000s, which was sought by MBNA, one of Delaware's largest companies, and other credit card issuers.[17] Biden allowed an amendment to the bill to increase the homestead exemption for homeowners declaring bankruptcy and fought for an amendment to forbid anti-abortion felons from using bankruptcy to discharge fines; the overall bill was vetoed by Bill Clinton in 2000 but then finally passed as the Bankruptcy Abuse Prevention and Consumer Protection Act in 2005, with Biden supporting it.[17] Biden held up trade agreements with Russia when that country stopped importing U.S. chickens. The downstateSussex County region is the nation's top chicken-producing area.[142] In 2007, Biden requested and gained $67 million worth of projects for his constituents through congressional earmarks.[151] ReputationBiden's official Senate photo (2005) Following his initial election in 1972, Biden was re-elected to six additional terms, in the elections of 1978, 1984, 1990, 1996, 2002, and 2008, usually getting about 60 percent of the vote.[142] He did not face strong opposition; Pete du Pont, then governor, chose not to run against him in 1984.[77] Biden spent 28 years as a junior senator due to the two-year seniority of his Republican colleague William V. Roth Jr.After Roth was defeated for re-election by Tom Carper in 2000, Biden became Delaware's senior senator. He then became the longest-serving senator in Delaware history[152] and, as of 2018, was the 18th longest serving senator in the history of the United States.[153] In May 1999, Biden became the youngest senator to cast 10,000 votes.[131] With a net worth between $59,000 and $366,000, and almost no outside income or investment income, Biden was consistently ranked as one of the least wealthy members of the Senate.[154][155][156] Biden stated that he was listed as the second-poorest member in Congress; he was not proud of the distinction, but attributed it to having been elected early in his career.[157]Biden realized early in his senatorial career how vulnerable poorer public officials are to offers of financial contributions in exchange for policy support, and he pushed campaign finance reform measures during his first term.[77] Biden earned $15.6 million in 2017-2018.[158] By 2019, Biden's middle class status was referred to as a "state of mind".[159] Biden's assets increased to between $2.2 million and $8 million.[160] During his years as a senator, Biden amassed a reputation for loquaciousness,[161][162][163] with his questions and remarks during Senate hearings being known as long-winded.[164][165] He has been a strong speaker and debater and a frequent and effective guest on Sunday morning talk shows.[165] In public appearances, he is known to deviate from prepared remarks at will.[166] According to political analyst Mark Halperin, he has shown "a persistent tendency to say silly, offensive, and off-putting things";[165] The New York Times writes that Biden's "weak filters make him capable of blurting out pretty much anything".[163] Journalist James Traub has written that "Biden's vanity and his regard for his own gifts seem considerable even by the rarefied standards of the U.S. Senate."[135] The political writer Howard Fineman has said, "Biden is not an academic, he's not a theoretical thinker, he's a great street pol. He comes from a long line of working people in Scranton—auto salesmen, car dealers, people who know how to make a sale. He has that great Irish gift."[41] olitical columnist David S. Broder has viewed Biden as having grown since he came to Washington and since his failed 1988 presidential bid: "He responds to real people—that's been consistent throughout. And his ability to understand himself and deal with other politicians has gotten much much better."[41] Traub concludes that "Biden is the kind of fundamentally happy person who can be as generous toward others as he is to himself."[135] 2008 presidential campaignBiden's 2008 campaign logo Biden had thought about running for president again ever since his failed 1988 bid.[nb 2] Biden declared his candidacy for President on January 31, 2007, after having discussed running for months prior.[169] Biden made a formal announcement to Tim Russert on Meet the Press, stating he would "be the best Biden I can be".[170] In January 2006, Delaware newspaper columnist Harry F. Themal wrote that Biden "occupies the sensible center of the Democratic Party".[171] Themal concludes that this is the position Biden desires, and that in a campaign "he plans to stress the dangers to the security of the average American, not just from the terrorist threat, but from the lack of health assistance, crime, and energy dependence on unstable parts of the world".[171] During his campaign, Biden focused on the war in Iraq and his support for the implementation of the Biden-Gelb plan to achieve political success. He touted his record in the Senate as the head of major congressional committees and his experience on foreign policy. Despite speculation to the contrary,[172]Biden rejected the notion of accepting the position of Secretary of State, focusing only on the presidency. At a 2007 campaign event, Biden said, "I know a lot of my opponents out there say I'd be a great Secretary of State. Seriously, every one of them. Do you watch any of the debates? 'Joe's right, Joe's right, Joe's right.'"[173] Other candidates' comments that "Joe is right" in the Democratic debates were converted into a Biden campaign theme and ad.[174] In mid-2007, Biden stressed his foreign policy expertise compared to Obama's, saying of the latter, "I think he can be ready, but right now I don't believe he is. The presidency is not something that lends itself to on-the-job training."[175] Biden also said that Obama was copying some of his foreign policy ideas.[135] Biden was noted for his one-liners on the campaign trail, saying of Republican then-frontrunner Rudy Giuliani at the debate on October 30, 2007, in Philadelphia, "There's only three things he mentions in a sentence: a noun, and a verb and 9/11."[176] Overall, Biden's debate performances were an effective mixture of humor, and sharp and surprisingly disciplined comments.[177] Biden made remarks during the campaign that attracted controversy. On the day of his January 2007 announcement, he spoke of fellow Democratic candidate and Senator Barack Obama: "I mean, you got the first mainstream African-American who is articulate and bright and clean and a nice-looking guy, I mean, that's a storybook, man."[178][nb 3] This comment undermined his campaign as soon as it began and significantly damaged his fund-raising capabilities;[177] it later took second place on Time magazine's list of Top 10 Campaign Gaffes for 2007.[180] Biden had earlier been criticized in July 2006 for a remark he made about his support among Indian Americans: "I've had a great relationship. In Delaware, the largest growth in population is Indian-Americans moving from India. You cannot go to a 7-Eleven or a Dunkin' Donuts unless you have a slight Indian accent. I'm not joking."[181] Biden later said the remark was not intended to be derogatory.[181][nb 4] Overall, Biden had difficulty raising funds, struggled to draw people to his rallies, and failed to gain traction against the high-profile candidacies of Obama and Senator Hillary Clinton;[183] he never rose above single digits in the national polls of the Democratic candidates. In the initial contest on January 3, 2008, Biden placed fifth in the Iowa caucuses, garnering slightly less than one percent of the state delegates.[184] Biden withdrew from the race that evening, saying "There is nothing sad about tonight. ... I feel no regret."[185] Despite the lack of success, Biden's stature in the political world rose as the result of his 2008 campaign.[177] In particular, it changed the relationship between Biden and Obama. Although the two had served together on theSenate Foreign Relations Committee, they had not been close, with Biden having resented Obama's quick rise to political stardom,[135][186] and Obama having viewed Biden as garrulous and patronizing.[187] Now, having gotten to know each other during 2007, Obama appreciated Biden's campaigning style and appeal to working class voters, and Biden was convinced that Obama was "the real deal".[186][187] 2008 vice presidential campaignSince shortly following Biden's withdrawal from the presidential race, Obama had been privately telling Biden that he was interested in finding an important place for him in a possible Obama administration.[188] Biden declined Obama's first request to vet him for the vice presidential slot, fearing the vice presidency would represent a loss in status and voice from his Senate position, but subsequently changed his mind.[135][189] In a June 22, 2008, interview on NBC's Meet the Press, Biden confirmed that, although he was not actively seeking a spot on the ticket, he would accept the vice presidential nomination if offered.[190] In early August, Obama and Biden met in secret to discuss a possible vice-presidential relationship,[188] and the two developed a strong personal rapport.[186] On August 22, 2008, Barack Obama announced that Biden would be his running mate.[191][192] The New York Times reported that the strategy behind the choice reflected a desire to fill out the ticket with someone who has foreign policyand national security experience—and not to help the ticket win a swing state or to emphasize Obama's "change" message.[193] Other observers pointed out Biden's appeal to middle class and blue-collar voters, as well as his willingness to aggressively challenge Republican nominee John McCain in a way that Obama seemed uncomfortable doing at times.[194][195] In accepting Obama's offer, Biden ruled out to him the possibility of running for president again in 2016[188] (although comments by Biden in subsequent years seemed to back off that stance, with Biden not wanting to diminish his political power by appearing uninterested in advancement).[196][197][198] Biden was officially nominated for vice president on August 27 by voice vote at the2008 Democratic National Convention in Denver, Colorado.[199] After his selection as a vice presidential candidate, Biden was criticized by his own Roman Catholic Diocese of Wilmington Bishop Michael Saltarelli for not opposing abortion.[200] The diocese confirmed that even if elected vice president, Biden would not be allowed to speak at Catholic schools.[201] Biden was soon barred from receiving Holy Communion by the bishop of his original hometown of Scranton, Pennsylvania, because of his support for abortion rights;[202] however, Biden did continue to receive Communion at his local Delaware parish.[201] Scranton became a flash point in the competition for swing state Catholic voters between the Democratic campaign and liberal Catholic groups, who stressed that other social issues should be considered as much or more than abortion, and many bishops and conservative Catholics, who maintained abortion was paramount.[203] Biden said he believed that life began at conception but that he would not impose his personal religious views on others.[204] Bishop Saltarelli had previously stated regarding stances similar to Biden's: "No one today would accept this statement from any public servant: 'I am personally opposed to human slavery and racism but will not impose my personal conviction in the legislative arena.' Likewise, none of us should accept this statement from any public servant: 'I am personally opposed to abortion but will not impose my personal conviction in the legislative arena.'"[201] Biden's vice presidential campaigning gained little media visibility, as far greater press attention was focused on the Republican running mate, Alaskan Governor Sarah Palin.[163][205] During one week in September 2008, for instance, the Pew Research Center's Project for Excellence in Journalismfound that Biden was included in only five percent of the news coverage of the race, far less than for the other three candidates on the tickets.[206] Biden nevertheless focused on campaigning in economically challenged areas ofswing states and trying to win over blue-collar Democrats, especially those who had supported Hillary Clinton.[135][163] Biden attacked McCain heavily, despite a long-standing personal friendship;[nb 5] he would say, "That guy I used to know, he's gone. It literally saddens me."[163] As the financial crisis of 2007–2010 reached a peak with the liquidity crisis of September 2008 and the proposed bailout of the United States financial system became a major factor in the campaign, Biden voted in favor of the $700 billionEmergency Economic Stabilization Act of 2008, which passed the Senate 74–25.[208] On October 2, 2008, Biden participated in the campaign's one vice presidential debate with Palin. Post-debate polls found that while Palin exceeded many voters' expectations, Biden had won the debate overall.[209] On October 5, Biden suspended campaign events for a few days after the death of his mother-in-law.[210] During the final days of the campaign, Biden focused on less-populated, older, less well-off areas of battleground states, especially in Florida, Ohio, and Pennsylvania, where polling indicated he was popular and where Obama had not campaigned or performed well in the Democratic primaries.[211][212][213] He also campaigned in some normally Republican states, as well as in areas with large Catholic populations.[213] Under instructions from the Obama campaign, Biden kept his speeches succinct and tried to avoid off-hand remarks, such as one about Obama's being tested by a foreign power soon after taking office, which had attracted negative attention.[211][212] rivately, Obama was frustrated by Biden's remarks, saying "How many times is Biden gonna say something stupid?"[214] Obama campaign staffers referred to Biden blunders as "Joe bombs" and kept Biden uninformed about strategy discussions, which in turn irked Biden.[198] Relations between the two campaigns became strained for a month, until Biden apologized on a call to Obama and the two built a stronger partnership.[214] ublicly, Obama strategist David Axelrod said that any unexpected comments had been outweighed by Biden's high popularity ratings.[215] Nationally, Biden had a 60 percent favorability rating in a Pew Research Center poll, compared to Palin's 44 percent.[211] On November 4, 2008, Obama was elected President and Biden was elected Vice President of the United States.[216] The Obama–Biden ticket won 365 Electoral College votes to McCain–Palin's 173,[217] and had a 53–46 percent edge in the nationwide popular vote.[218] Biden had continued to run for his Senate seat as well as for Vice President,[219] as permitted by Delaware law.[142][nb 6] On November 4, Biden was also re-elected as senator, defeating Republican Christine O'Donnell.[220] Having won both races, Biden made a point of holding off his resignation from the Senate so that he could be sworn in for his seventh term on January 6, 2009.[221] He became the youngest senator ever to start a seventh full term, and said, "In all my life, the greatest honor bestowed upon me has been serving the people of Delaware as their United States senator."[221] Biden cast his last Senate vote on January 15, supporting the release of the second $350 billion for the Troubled Asset Relief Program.[222] Biden resigned from the Senate later that day;[nb 7] in emotional farewell remarks on the Senate floor, where he had spent most of his adult life, Biden said, "Every good thing I have seen happen here, every bold step taken in the 36-plus years I have been here, came not from the application of pressure by interest groups, but through the maturation of personal relationships."[226] Vice Presidency (2009–2017)Post-election transitionOn November 4, 2008, Biden was elected Vice President of the United States as Obama's running mate. Soon after the election, he was appointed chairman of President-elect Obama's transition team. During the transition phase of the Obama administration, Biden said he was in daily meetings with Obama and that McCain was still his friend.[227] The U.S. Secret Service codename given to Biden is "Celtic", referencing his Irish roots.[228] Biden chose veteran Democratic lawyer and aide Ron Klain to be his chief of staff,[229] and Time Washington bureau chief Jay Carney to be his director of communications.[230] Biden intended to eliminate some of the explicit roles assumed by the vice presidency of his predecessor, Dick Cheney,[231] who had established himself as an autonomous power center.[135] Otherwise, Biden said he would not emulate any previous vice presidency, but would instead seek to provide advice and counsel on every critical decision Obama would make.[232] Biden said he was closely involved in all the cabinet appointments that were made during the transition.[232] Biden was also named to head the new White House Task Force on Working Families, an initiative aimed at improving the economic well being of the middle class.[233] In his last act as Chairman of the Foreign Relations Committee, Biden went on a trip to Iraq, Afghanistan and Pakistan during the second week of January 2009, meeting with the leadership of those countries.[234] First term (2009–2013)On January 20, 2009, at noon, Biden became the 47th Vice President of the United States, sworn into the office by Supreme Court Justice John Paul Stevens.[235] Biden is the first United States Vice President from Delaware[236] and the first Roman Catholic to attain that office.[237] President Obama walking with Vice President Biden at the White House, February 2009 In the early months of the Obama administration, Biden assumed the role of an important behind-the-scenes counselor.[238] One role was to adjudicate disputes between Obama's "team of rivals".[135] The president compared Biden's efforts to a basketball player "who does a bunch of things that don't show up in the stat sheet".[238] Biden played a key role in gaining Senate support for several major pieces of Obama legislation, and was a main factor in convincing Senator Arlen Specter to switch from the Republican to the Democratic party.[239] Biden lost an internal debate to Secretary of StateHillary Clinton regarding his opposition to sending 21,000 new troops to thewar in Afghanistan.[240][241] His skeptical voice was still considered valuable within the administration,[189] however, and later in 2009 Biden's views achieved more prominence within the White House as Obama reconsidered his Afghanistan strategy.[242] Biden made visits to Iraq about once every two months,[135] including trips to Baghdad in August and September 2009 to listen to Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki and reiterate U.S. stances on Iraq's future;[243] by this time he had become the administration's point man in delivering messages to Iraqi leadership about expected progress in the country.[189] More generally, overseeing Iraq policy became Biden's responsibility: the president is said to have put it as "Joe, you do Iraq".[244] Biden said Iraq "could be one of the great achievements of this administration".[245] Biden's January 2010 visit to Iraq in the midst of turmoil over banned candidates from the upcoming Iraqi parliamentary election resulted in 59 of the several hundred candidates being reinstated by the Iraqi government two days later.[246] By 2012, Biden had made eight trips there, but his oversight of U.S. policy in Iraq receded with the exit in 2011 of U.S. troops.[247][248] Biden was also in charge of the oversight role for infrastructure spending from the Obama stimulus packageintended to help counteract the ongoing recession, and stressed that only worthy projects should get funding.[249]He talked with hundreds of governors, mayors, and other local officials in this role.[247] During this period, Biden was satisfied that no major instances of waste or corruption had occurred,[189] and when he completed that role in February 2011, he said that the number of fraud incidents with stimulus monies had been less than one percent.[250] resident_Barack_Obama_and_Vice_President_Joe_Biden_shake_hands_in_the_Oval_Office_following_a_phone_call_with_House_Speaker_John_Boehner_securing_a_bipartisan_deal_to_reduce_the_nation%27s_deficit_and_avoid_default.jpg" class="image" style="text-decoration: none; color: rgb(11, 0, 128); background: none;"> resident_Barack_Obama_and_Vice_President_Joe_Biden_shake_hands_in_the_Oval_Office_following_a_phone_call_with_House_Speaker_John_Boehner_securing_a_bipartisan_deal_to_reduce_the_nation%27s_deficit_and_avoid_default.jpg" class="internal" title="Enlarge" style="text-decoration: none; color: rgb(11, 0, 128); display: block; text-indent: 15px; white-space: nowrap; overflow: hidden; width: 15px; height: 11px; -webkit-user-select: none; background: linear-gradient(transparent, transparent), url("data:image/svg+xml,%3Csvg xmlns=%22http://www.w3.org/2000/svg%22 width=%2215%22 height=%2211%22 viewBox=%220 0 11 15%22%3E %3Cg id=%22magnify-clip%22 fill=%22%23fff%22 stroke=%22%23000%22%3E %3Cpath id=%22bigbox%22 d=%22M1.509 1.865h10.99v7.919H1.509z%22/%3E %3Cpath id=%22smallbox%22 d=%22M-1.499 6.868h5.943v4.904h-5.943z%22/%3E %3C/g%3E %3C/svg%3E");"> President Obama congratulates Biden for his role in shaping the debt ceiling deal that led to the Budget Control Act of 2011. It took some time for the cautious Obama and the blunt, rambling Biden to work out ways of dealing with each other.[198] In late April 2009, Biden's off-message response to a question during the beginning of the swine flu outbreak, that he would advise family members against travelling on airplanes or subways, led to a swift retraction from the White House.[251] The remark revived Biden's reputation for gaffes,[252] and led to a spate of late-night television jokes themed on him being a loose-talking buffoon.[242][253][254] In the face of persistently rising unemployment through July 2009, Biden acknowledged that the administration had "misread how bad the economy was" but maintained confidence that the stimulus package would create many more jobs once the pace of expenditures picked up.[255] The same month, Secretary of State Clinton quickly disavowed Biden's remarks disparaging Russia as a power, but despite any missteps, Biden still retained Obama's confidence and was increasingly influential within the administration.[256] On March 23, 2010, a microphone picked up Biden telling the president that his signing of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act was "a big ... deal", using an adjective beginning with "f", during live national news telecasts. White House press secretary Robert Gibbs replied via Twitter "And yes Mr. Vice President, you're right ..."[257] Despite their different personalities, Obama and Biden formed a friendship, partly based around Obama's daughter Sasha and Biden's granddaughter Maisy, who attended Sidwell Friends Schooltogether.[198] Biden's most important role within the administration was to question assumptions, playing a contrarian role.[135][242] Obama said that "The best thing about Joe is that when we get everybody together, he really forces people to think and defend their positions, to look at things from every angle, and that is very valuable for me."[189] Another senior Obama advisor said Biden "is always prepared to be the skunk at the family picnic to make sure we are as intellectually honest as possible".[189] On June 11, 2010, Biden represented the United States at the opening ceremony of the World Cup, attended the England v. U.S. game which was tied 1–1, and visited Egypt, Kenya, and South Africa.[258] Throughout, Joe and Jill Biden maintained a relaxed atmosphere at their official residence in Washington, often entertaining some of their grandchildren, and regularly returned to their home in Delaware.[259] Biden campaigned heavily for Democrats in the 2010 midterm elections, maintaining an attitude of optimism in the face of general predictions of large-scale losses for the party.[260] Following large-scale Republican gains in the elections and the departure of White House Chief of Staff Rahm Emanuel, Biden's past relationships with Republicans in Congress became more important.[261][262] He led the successful administration effort to gain Senate approval for the New START treaty.[261][262] In December 2010, Biden's advocacy within the White House for a middle ground, followed by his direct negotiations with Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell, were instrumental in producing the administration's compromise tax package that revolved around a temporaryextension of the Bush tax cuts.[262][263] Biden then took the lead in trying to sell the agreement to a reluctant Democratic caucus in Congress,[262][264] which was passed as the Tax Relief, Unemployment Insurance Reauthorization, and Job Creation Act of 2010. In foreign policy, Biden supported the NATO-led military intervention in Libya in 2011.[265] Biden has supported closer economic ties with Russia.[266] In March 2011, Obama detailed Biden to lead negotiations between both houses of Congress and the White House in resolving federal spending levels for the rest of the year, and avoiding a government shutdown.[267] By May 2011, a "Biden panel" with six congressional members was trying to reach a bipartisan deal on raising theU.S. debt ceiling as part of an overall deficit reduction plan.[268][269] The U.S. debt ceiling crisis developed over the next couple of months, but it was again Biden's relationship with McConnell that proved to be a key factor in breaking a deadlock and finally bringing about a bipartisan deal to resolve it, in the form of the Budget Control Act of 2011, signed on August 2, 2011, the same day that an unprecedented U.S. default had loomed.[270][271][272] Biden had spent the most time bargaining with Congress on the debt question of anyone in the administration,[271] and one Republican staffer said, "Biden's the only guy with real negotiating authority, and [McConnell] knows that his word is good. He was a key to the deal."[270] It has been reported that Biden was opposed to going forward with the May 2011 U.S. mission to kill Osama bin Laden,[247][273] lest failure adversely affect Obama's chances for a second term.[274][275] He took the lead in notifying Congressional leaders of the successful outcome.[276] 2012 re-election campaignIn October 2010, Biden stated that Obama had asked him to remain as his running mate for the 2012 presidential election.[260] With Obama's popularity on the decline, however, in late 2011 White House Chief of Staff William M. Daley conducted some secret polling and focus group research into the idea of Secretary of State Clinton replacing Biden on the ticket.[277] The notion was dropped when the results showed no appreciable improvement for Obama,[277] and White House officials later said that Obama had never entertained the idea.[278] Biden's May 2012 statement that he was "absolutely comfortable" with same-sex marriage gained considerable public attention in comparison to President Obama's position, which had been described as "evolving".[279]Biden made his statement without administration consent, and Obama and his aides were quite irked, since Obama had planned to shift position several months later, in the build-up to the party convention, and since Biden had previously counseled the president to avoid the issue lest key Catholic voters be offended.[198][280][281][282] Gay rights advocates seized upon the Biden stance,[280] and within days, Obama announced that he too supported same-sex marriage, an action in part forced by Biden's unexpected remarks.[283] Biden apologized to Obama in private for having spoken out,[281][284] while Obama acknowledged publicly it had been done from the heart.[280] The incident showed that Biden still struggled at times withmessage discipline;[198] as Time wrote, "everyone knows [that] Biden's greatest strength is also his greatest weakness."[247] Relations were also strained between the campaigns when Biden appeared to use his to bolster fundraising contacts for a possible run on his own in the 2016 presidential election, and the vice president ended up being excluded from Obama campaign strategy meetings.[277] Biden with President Barack Obama, July 2012 The Obama campaign nevertheless still valued Biden as a retail-level politician who could connect with disaffected, blue collar workers and rural residents, and he had a heavy schedule of appearances in swing states as the Obama re-election campaignbegan in earnest in spring 2012.[110][247] An August 2012 remark before a mixed-race audience that proposed Republican relaxation of Wall Street regulations would "put y'all back in chains" led to a similar analysis of Biden's face-to-face campaigning abilities versus tendency to go off track.[110][285][286] The Los Angeles Times wrote, "Most candidates give the same stump speech over and over, putting reporters if not the audience to sleep. But during any Biden speech, there might be a dozen moments to make press handlers cringe, and prompt reporters to turn to each other with amusement and confusion."[285] Time magazine wrote that Biden often goes too far and that "Along with the familiar Washington mix of neediness and overconfidence, Biden's brain is wired for more than the usual amount of goofiness."[110] Biden was officially nominated for a second term as vice president on September 6 by voice vote at the 2012 Democratic National Convention in Charlotte, North Carolina.[287] He faced his Republican counterpart, Representative Paul Ryan, in the lone 2012 vice presidential debate on October 11 in Danville, Kentucky. There he made a feisty, emotional defense of the Obama administration's record and energetically attacked the Republican ticket, in an effort to regain campaign momentum lost by Obama's unfocused debate performance against Republican nominee Mitt Romney the week before.[288][289] On November 6, 2012, the president and vice president were elected to second terms.[290] The Obama–Biden ticket won 332 Electoral College votes to Romney–Ryan's 206 and had a 51–47 percent edge in the nationwide popular vote.[291] Post-electionIn December 2012, Biden was named by Obama to head the Gun Violence Task Force, created to address the causes of gun violence in the United States in the aftermath of the Sandy Hook Elementary School shooting.[292]Later that month, during the final days before the country fell off the "fiscal cliff", Biden's relationship with McConnell once more proved important as the two negotiated a deal that led to the American Taxpayer Relief Act of 2012being passed at the start of 2013.[293][294] It made permanent much of the Bush tax cuts but raised rates on upper income levels.[294] Second term (2013–2017)Biden was inaugurated to a second term in the early morning of January 20, 2013, at a small ceremony in his official residence with Justice Sonia Sotomayor presiding (a public ceremony took place on January 21).[295] He continued to be in the forefront as, in the wake of the Sandy Hook Elementary School shooting, the Obama administration put forth executive orders and proposed legislation towards new gun control measures[115] (the legislation failed to pass).[296] During the discussions that led to the October 2013 passage of the Continuing Appropriations Act, 2014, which resolved the U.S. federal government shutdown of 2013 and the U.S. debt-ceiling crisis of 2013, Biden played little role. This was due to Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid and other Democratic leaders cutting the vice president out of any direct talks with Congress, feeling that Biden had given too much away during previous negotiations.[297][298][299] Biden's Violence Against Women Act was reauthorized again in 2013. The act led to further related developments in the creation of the White House Council on Women and Girls, begun in the first term, as well as the White House Task Force to Protect Students from Sexual Assault, begun in January 2014 with Biden as co-chair along with Jarrett.[301][302] Biden has a strong stance on sexual assault.[303] For example, Biden stated to a victim of sexual assault at Stanford University, "you did it ... in the hope that your strength might prevent this crime from happening to someone else. Your bravery is breathtaking."[303]He has also taken legality into the situation. Biden issued federal guidelines while presenting a speech at the University of New Hampshire. He stated that "No means no, if you're drunk or you're sober. No means no if you're in bed, in a dorm or on the street. No means no even if you said yes at first and you changed your mind. No means no."[304][305][306] Biden favored arming Syria's rebel fighters.[307] As Iraq fell apart during 2014, renewed attention was paid to the Biden-Gelb Iraqi federalization plan of 2006, with some observers suggesting that Biden had been right all along.[308][309] Biden himself said that the U.S. would follow ISIL "to the gates of hell".[310] In October 2014, Biden said that Turkey, Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates had "poured hundreds of millions of dollars and tens of thousands of tons of weapons into anyone who would fight against Al-Assad, except that the people who were being supplied were al-Nusra, and al Qaeda, and the extremist elements of jihadis coming from other parts of the world."[311] Biden with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu in Jerusalem, March 9, 2016. Biden is a staunch supporter of Israel. By 2015, a series of swearings-in and other events where Biden placed his hands on women and girls and talked closely to them had attracted the attention of both the press and social media.[312][313][314][315] In one case, a senator issued a statement afterward saying about his daughter, "No, she doesn't think the vice president is creepy."[316] On January 17, 2015, Secret Service agents heard shots were fired as a vehicle drove near Biden's Delaware residence at 8:28 p.m. outside the security perimeter, but the vice president and his wife Jill were not home. A vehicle was observed by an agent speeding away.[317] On December 8, 2015, Biden spoke in Ukraine's parliament in Kiev[318][319] in one of his many visits to set USA aid and policy stance for Ukraine.[320] On February 28, 2016, Biden gave a speech at the 88th Academy Awards to do with awareness for sexual assault; he also introduced Lady Gaga. In March 2016, Biden spoke at the American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC) olicy Conference inWashington, D.C.[321] In his speech, he stated, "We're all united by our unyielding—I mean literally unyielding—commitment to the survival, the security, and the success of the Jewish State of Israel."[321] On December 8, 2016, Biden went to Ottawa to meet with the Prime Minister of Canada, Justin Trudeau.[322] During his two full terms, Joe Biden never cast a tie-breaking vote in the Senate, making him the longest serving Vice President with this distinction.[citation needed] Death of Beau BidenOn May 30, 2015, Biden's son, Beau Biden, died at age 46 after having battled brain cancer for several years. In a statement, the Vice President's office said, "The entire Biden family is saddened beyond words."[323] The nature and seriousness of the illness had not been previously disclosed to the public, and Biden had quietly reduced his public schedule in order to spend more time with his son. At the time of his death, Beau Biden had been widely seen as the frontrunner to be the Democratic nominee for Governor of Delaware in 2016.[65][66] Role in the 2016 presidential campaignDuring much of his second term, Biden was said to be preparing for a possible bid for the 2016 Democratic presidential nomination.[324] At age 74 on Inauguration Day in January 2017, he would have been the oldest president on inauguration in history.[325] With his family, many friends, and donors encouraging him in mid-2015 to enter the race, and with Hillary Clinton's favorability ratings in decline at that time, Biden was reported to again be seriously considering the prospect and a "Draft Biden 2016" PAC was established.[324][326][327] As of September 11, 2015, Biden was still uncertain whether or not to run. Biden cited the recent death of his son being a large drain on his emotional energy, and that "nobody has a right ... to seek that office unless they're willing to give it 110% of who they are".[328] On October 21, speaking from a podium in the Rose Garden with his wife and President Obama by his side, Biden announced his decision not to enter the race for the Democratic presidential nomination in the 2016 election.[329][330][331] In January 2016, Biden affirmed that not running was the right decision, but admitted to regretting not running for President "every day."[332][333] As of the end of January 2016, neither Biden nor President Barack Obama had endorsed any candidate in the 2016 presidential election. Biden did miss his annual Thanksgiving tradition of going to Nantucket, opting instead to travel abroad and meet with several European leaders. He took time to meet with Martin O'Malley, having previously met with Bernie Sanders, both 2016 candidates. Neither of these meetings was considered an endorsement, as Biden had said that he would meet with any candidate who asked.[334] Biden meeting with Vice President–elect Mike Pence on November 10, 2016 After Obama endorsed Hillary Clinton on June 9, 2016, Biden endorsed her later the same day.[335] Though Biden and Clinton were scheduled to campaign together in Scranton on July 8, the appearance was canceled by Clinton in light of the shooting of Dallas police officers the previous day.[336] Following his endorsement of Clinton, Biden publicly displayed his disagreements with the policies of Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump. On June 20, Biden critiqued Trump's proposal to temporarily ban Muslims from entering the country as well as his stated intent to build a wallbetween the United States and Mexico border, furthering that Trump's suggestion to either torture and or kill family members of terrorists was both damaging to American values and "deeply damaging to our security".[337] During an interview with George Stephanopoulos at the 2016 Democratic National Convention on July 26, Biden asserted that "moral and centered" voters would not vote for Trump.[338]On October 21, the anniversary of his choice to not run, Biden said he wished he was still in high school so he could take Trump "behind the gym".[339] On October 24, Biden clarified he would only have fought Trump if he was still in high school,[340] and the following day, October 25, Trump responded that he would "love that".[341] Post–Vice Presidency (2017–present)Biden campaigning for Alabama U.S. Senate candidate Doug Jones in October 2017 In 2017, Biden was named the Benjamin Franklin Presidential Practice professor at the University of Pennsylvania, where he intended to focus on foreign policy, diplomacy, and national security while leading the Penn Biden Center for Diplomacy and Global Engagement.[3] He also wanted to pursue his "cancer moonshot" agenda,[342] calling the fight against cancer "the only bipartisan thing left in America" in March 2017.[343] Biden had been close friends with Sen. John McCain for over 30 years. In 2018, Sen. McCain died at the age of 81 after dealing with the same cancer that Joe Biden's late son Beau Biden died of. Biden gave the eulogy at McCain's funeral service in Phoenix, Arizona. He opened with "My name's Joe Biden. I'm a Democrat. And I loved John McCain.",[344] he also called him a "brother".[344] Biden also served as a pallbearer at Sen. McCain's memorial service at the Washington National Cathedral alongside Warren Beatty, and Michael Bloomberg.[345] While attending the launch of the Penn Biden Center for Diplomacy and Global Engagement on March 30, 2017, a student asked Biden what "piece of advice" he would give to President Trump, Biden responding that the president should grow up and cease his tweeting so he could focus on the office.[346] During a speech at a May 29, 2017 gathering of Philip D. Murphy supporters at a community center gymnasium, Biden said, "There are a lot of people out there who are frightened. Trump played on their fears. What we haven't done, in my view—and this is a criticism of all us—we haven't spoken enough to the fears and aspirations of the people we come from."[347] On June 17, 2017, Biden predicted the "state the nation is today will not be sustained by the American people" while speaking at a Florida Democratic Party fundraiser in Hollywood.[348] Biden told CBS This Morning that Trump's administration "seems to feel the need to coddle autocrats and dictators" like Saudi Arabian leaders, Russian President Putin, North Korean leader Kim Jong-un or Philippine President Rodrigo Duterte.[349] In October 2018, Biden said if Democrats retake the House of Representatives, "I hope they don't [impeach Trump]. I don't think there's a basis for doing that right now."[350] Climate changeDuring an appearance at the Brainstorm Health Conference in San Diego, California on May 2, 2017, Biden said the public "has moved ahead of the administration [on science]".[351] On May 31, Biden tweeted that climate change was an "existential threat to our future" and remaining in the Paris Agreement was the "best way to protect our children and global leadership."[352] The following day, after President Trump announced his withdrawal of the US from the Paris Agreement, Biden tweeted that the choice "imperils US security and our ability to own the clean energy future."[353] While appearing at the Concordia Europe Summit in Athens, Greeceon June 7, Biden said, referring to the Paris Agreement, "The vast majority of the American people do not agree with the decision the president made."[354] HealthcareOn March 22, 2017, Biden referred to the Republican healthcare bill as a "tax bill" meant to transfer nearly US$1 trillion used for health benefits for the lower classes to wealthy Americans during his first appearance on Capitol Hill since Trump's inauguration.[355] On May 4, after the House of Representatives narrowly voted for theAmerican Health Care Act, Biden tweeted that it was a "Day of shame for Congress", lamenting the loss of pre-existing condition protections.[356] On June 24, in response to Senate Republicans revealing an American Health Care Act draft the previous day, Biden tweeted that the bill "isn't about health care at all—it's a wealth transfer: slashes care to fund tax cuts for the wealthy & corporations".[357] On July 28, in response to the Republican Senate healthcare bill falling through, Biden tweeted, "Thank you to everyone who tirelessly worked to protect the healthcare of millions."[358] ImmigrationOn September 5, 2017, after Attorney General Jeff Sessions announced that the Trump Administration is rescinding the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals, Biden tweeted, "Brought by parents, these children had no choice in coming here. Now they'll be sent to countries they've never known. Cruel. Not America."[359] LGBT rightsOn April 14, 2017, Biden released a statement both denouncing the authorities in Chechnya for their rounding up, torturing, and murdering of "individuals who are believed to be gay" and stating his hope that the Trump administration honor a prior pledge to advance human rights by confronting Chechen leader Ramzan Kadyrovand Russian leaders over "these egregious violations of human rights".[360] On June 21, during a speech at a Democratic National Committee LGBT gala in New York City, Biden said, "Hold President Trump accountable for his pledge to be your friend."[361] On July 26, 2017, after Trump announced a ban of transgender people serving in the military, Biden tweeted, "Every patriotic American who is qualified to serve in our military should be able to serve. Full stop."[362] In March 2019, Biden condemned Brunei's new LGBT death penalty law, tweeting: "Stoning people to death for homosexuality or adultery is appalling and immoral. There is no excuse – not culture, not tradition – for this kind of hate and inhumanity."[363] Biden suggested that the Trump administration's hostility to the rights of LGBT people was sending a poor example to countries like Brunei.[364] 2020 presidential campaignDuring a tour of the U.S. Senate with reporters before leaving office, on December 5, 2016, Biden refused to rule out a bid for the presidency in the2020 presidential election, after leaving office as Vice President. If he were to run in 2020, Biden would be 77 years old on election day and 78 on inauguration day in 2021.[365][366][367] He reasserted his ambivalence about running on an appearance of The Late Show with Stephen Colbert on December 7, in which he stated "never say never" about running for President in 2020, while also acknowledging that he did not see a scenario in which he would run for office again.[368][369] He seemingly announced on January 13, 2017, exactly one week prior to the expiration of his vice presidential term, that he would not run.[370] He then appeared to backtrack four days later, on January 17, stating "I'll run if I can walk."[371] A political action committee known as Time for Biden was formed in January 2018, seeking Biden's entry into the race.[372][373] Between 2016 and 2019, Biden was mentioned by various media outlets as a potential candidate. He told a forum held in Bogota, Colombia, on July 17, 2018, that he would decide whether or not to formally declare as a candidate by January 2019.[374] On February 4, 2019, with no decision having been forthcoming from Biden, Edward-Isaac Dovere of The Atlantic wrote that Biden was "very close to saying yes" but that some close to him are worried he would have a last-minute change of heart, as he did in 2016.[375] Dovere reported that Biden was concerned about the effect another presidential run could have on his family and reputation, as well as fundraising struggles and perceptions about his age and relative centrism, compared to other declared and potential candidates.[375] Conversely, his "sense of duty," offense at the Trump presidency, the lack of foreign policy experience amongst other Democratic hopefuls and his desire to foster "bridge-building progressivism" in the Party, were said to be factors prompting him to run.[375] In March 2019, he indicated he may run,[376] and ultimately launched his campaign on April 25, 2019.[377] In May 2019, Biden chose Philadelphia to be his 2020 U.S. presidential campaign headquarters.[378] While at a fundraiser on June 18, 2019, Biden said that one of his greatest strengths was "bringing people together" and pointed to his relationships with Senators James Eastland and Herman Talmadge, twosegregationists as examples. While imitating a Southern drawl, Biden remarked "I was in a caucus with James O. Eastland. He never called me 'boy,' he always called me 'son.'”[379][380] New Jersey Senator Cory Bookerwas one of many Democrats to criticize Biden for the remarks, issuing a statement that said "You don't joke about calling black men 'boys.' Men like James O. Eastland used words like that, and the racist policies that accompanied them, to perpetuate white supremacy and strip black Americans of our very humanity".[380] During the first Democratic presidential debate, Kamala Harris criticized Biden for his comments regarding his past work with segregationist Senators and his past opposition to desegregation busing that allowed black children like her to attend integrated schools.[381] Biden was widely criticized for his debate performance and support for him dropped 10 points.[382][383][384] resident Trump defended Biden, saying Harris was given "too much credit" for her debate with Biden.[385] On July 15, 2019, the non-profit Biden Cancer Initiative announced the foundation was ceasing operations for the foreseeable future. Biden and his wife left the initiative's board in April as an ethics precaution before starting his 2020 presidential campaign.[386] Allegations of inappropriate physical contactThere have been multiple photographs and videos of Biden engaged in what commentators considered to be inappropriate proximity to women and children, including kissing and or touching.[387][388][389] Biden has described himself as a "tactile politician" and admitted that this behavior has caused trouble for him in the past.[390] An image of Biden in close proximity to Stephanie Carter during her husband's swearing in asSecretary of Defense in 2015 resulted in a mocking epithet that was widely repeated. Carter defended Biden's depicted behavior in a 2019 interview.[391] In March 2019, former Nevada assemblywoman Lucy Flores alleged that Biden kissed her without her consent at a 2014 campaign rally in Las Vegas. In a New York magazine op-ed for The Cut, Flores wrote that Biden had walked up behind her, put his hands on her shoulders, smelled her hair, and kissed the back of her head. Adding that the way he touched her was "an intimate way reserved for close friends, family, or romantic partners – and I felt powerless to do anything about it."[392] In an interview with HuffPost, Flores stated she believed Biden's behavior to be disqualifying for a 2020 presidential run.[393] Biden's spokesman stated that Biden did not recall the behavior described.[394] Two days after Flores, Amy Lappos, a former congressional aide to Jim Himes, said Biden crossed a line of decency and respect when he touched her in a non-sexual, but inappropriate way by holding her head to rub noses with her at a political fundraiser in Greenwich in 2009.[395] The next day, two additional women came forward with allegations of inappropriate conduct. One woman said that Biden placed his hand on her thigh, and the other said he ran his hand from her shoulder down her back.[396][397] By early April 2019, a total of seven women had made allegations of inappropriate physical contact regarding Biden.[398] At a conference on April 5, Biden apologized for not understanding how individuals would react to his actions, but stated that his intentions were honorable; he went on to say that he was not sorry for anything that he had ever done, which led critics to accuse him of sending a mixed message.[399] He also proclaimed—with each public embrace he gave during the event—that he had received permission for it. Some critics interpreted this as Biden jokingly deflecting criticism, while other observers considered his change in tone responsive to the criticisms received.[400] |